Skip to content
Roel Smelt

14 Nov 2026 · 3 min read

The Magician Never Wins: Sandcastles in the Surf

Most of us were raised on one story. You start small, carrying old pain you do not quite understand. You work, you learn, you climb. And if you climb well, one day you become the person who bends life to his will. The successful entrepreneur. The magician.

Many people see that as the highest you can reach. In that story, the monk’s meditation is a rest. A recovery point, so you can go back to winning.

I believed a version of that story too. I also learned, early, that it does not end the way it promises.


During my graduation I had an assignment at NS, the Dutch railways, in Rotterdam. At the same time I had gone deep into Sociocracy, and I was an intern at the company of Professor Gerard Endenburg, also in Rotterdam.

He moved me deeply. Above all his humanity. And the way he showed me how entrenched positions work: when an organization is run through boards of directors on one side and works councils on the other, the human scale is the first thing to disappear. Everyone defends a pillar. Nobody meets.

So at NS I experimented. I let train drivers and conductors sit down with management and talk together, to find solutions together. Not each from their own side. As people who shared the same work.

It went very well.

Until higher management and the unions put a stop to it. It would have touched their entrenched positions.

Of course the system was stronger. It was the surf. But like Keating in Dead Poets Society, we had built our little sandcastle in the surf anyway. We were moved by it. And for a while, there was humanity.


That is the part the climbing story leaves out.

From the Buddha, the story runs the other way. The realized monk is the endpoint, not the pause between two victories. He has seen that we are all building sandcastles in the surf. Everything arises only to pass away. So every magician fails in the end.

The sandcastle at NS did not stand. It was never going to. But the building was ours. The drivers, the conductors, the managers who talked as people for a while: that act belonged to us. The outcome never did.

You can own your actions. You cannot own their outcomes. That insight is what takes you beyond the magician, and into self-realization. And it is not bitter. It is a kind of freedom.


That process is timeless. Technology does not change it. Technology is an externalization of human abilities. It says nothing about whether you stay stuck in your old pain, or whether you start to believe the new tools will finally make you the magician who wins. The irony is obvious. The temptation is too.

One thing is new. Technological progress lifts ever more people above the poverty line. More and more of us can live like kings, and in many ways we already do. For most of history, only a few ever got close enough to the magician’s victory to taste it. Now many more people can.

That makes it a personal choice. You can settle into that victory. You can live it fully, build every castle you can. And then, from your own experience and not from a book, see that the magician is only playing tic-tac-toe. There is always a next move. There is never a final win.

That seeing is what frees him.

You cannot skip the magician. You have to live him to see through him. That is why I welcome the acceleration of technology. It hands the old journey to many more people.

It does not hand them the last step.

But how many will actually come to realization?

Free to use and translate under CC BY 4.0